picklepicker.lol

Browse Gaming Would You Rather questions

Would You Rather questions for gamers and game devs — agonizing gamedev trade-offs and pure gamer dilemmas that put you in a real pickle.

64 questionsFree to playUpdated weekly

Play this pack Browse collections

Showing 1–50 of 64

#1 · Would you rather
Open
A) watch a streamer rage-quit your game live B) watch nobody stream it for a single minute
Good one?
#2 · Would you rather
Open
A) learn your favorite childhood game aged terribly B) never touch it and keep the memory perfect
Good one?
#3 · Would you rather
Open
A) play a game with perfect matchmaking and no friends online B) play with friends three ranks above you
Good one?
#4 · Would you rather
Open
A) carry your team every match and get no credit B) get carried and take all the praise
Good one?
#5 · Would you rather
Open
A) have unlimited money in every game you play B) keep the grind and the payoff it brings
Good one?
#6 · Would you rather
Open
A) lose your ranked promo match to a disconnect B) win it because the enemy team dodged
Good one?
#7 · Would you rather
Open
A) grind 200 hours for your game's rarest drop B) get it in your first hour by pure luck
Good one?
#8 · Would you rather
Open
A) let your publisher rename your game B) self-publish and reach almost nobody
Good one?
#9 · Would you rather
Open
A) spend your whole saturday wiping in your guild's raid B) skip it and hear about the clear for months
Good one?
#10 · Would you rather
Open
A) spoil your favorite game for a friend by accident B) have them spoil the ending of yours
Good one?
#11 · Would you rather
Open
A) quit your favorite live game the day it peaks B) stay until the servers shut down for good
Good one?
#12 · Would you rather
Open
A) keep voice chat on in every match forever B) mute everyone and miss every callout
Good one?
#13 · Would you rather
Open
A) have your best gaming moment happen with nobody watching B) have your worst one clipped and shared
Good one?
#14 · Would you rather
Open
A) delay your game's demo until it shines B) show it rough and let players judge early
Good one?
#15 · Would you rather
Open
A) put your game on sale at 90% off forever B) hold full price and sell a tenth as many
Good one?
#16 · Would you rather
Open
A) keep your studio alive on live-service updates B) make one finished game and start over
Good one?
#17 · Would you rather
Open
A) have your game review-bombed over one patch B) have it never talked about at all
Good one?
#18 · Would you rather
Open
A) play only the games your friends are into B) play only games nobody you know has heard of
Good one?
#19 · Would you rather
Open
A) play your favorite co-op game with a distracted friend B) finish it alone and share the win with nobody
Good one?
#20 · Would you rather
Open
A) have every game's story spoiled before you play it B) forget a game's entire story the moment you finish it
Good one?
#21 · Would you rather
Open
A) replay your comfort game for the hundredth time B) start the backlog you keep ignoring
Good one?
#22 · Would you rather
Open
A) beat your game's hardest boss on the first try B) beat it on the fiftieth and feel every hit
Good one?
#23 · Would you rather
Open
A) finish your game a week after everyone else B) rush it in a weekend and remember nothing
Good one?
#24 · Would you rather
Open
A) nail your game's launch but burn out your entire team B) protect your team but miss the launch window
Good one?
#25 · Would you rather
Open
A) have your save file corrupt at 90 hours B) start over with double the difficulty
Good one?
#26 · Would you rather
Open
A) make a game you love that probably won't sell B) make a game you find boring that's guaranteed to be a hit
Good one?
#27 · Would you rather
Open
A) have your game go viral for being hilariously broken B) launch it flawlessly and get completely ignored
Good one?
#28 · Would you rather
Open
A) launch your indie game the same week as a massive AAA title B) delay six months and lose all your pre-launch hype
Good one?
#29 · Would you rather
Open
A) quit any game forever the first time you lose B) be forced to finish every game you start, even the ones you hate
Good one?
#30 · Would you rather
Open
A) only ever play single-player games B) only ever play multiplayer games
Good one?
#31 · Would you rather
Open
A) discover a game-breaking bug one hour before the gold master is due B) find out a key feature was silently cut without telling you
Good one?
#32 · Would you rather
Open
A) get early access to every game but always riddled with bugs B) always wait a year but get the fully polished version
Good one?
#33 · Would you rather
Open
A) experience your favorite game for the first time again but forget it forever after B) keep all your memories but never replay it
Good one?
#34 · Would you rather
Open
A) have your studio's best idea stolen by a giant B) have it ignored by everyone including you
Good one?
#35 · Would you rather
Open
A) monetize with aggressive microtransactions and anger your fans B) stay player-friendly and watch the studio struggle to pay salaries
Good one?
#36 · Would you rather
Open
A) make your game with an unlimited budget but a fixed, unmovable deadline B) make it with unlimited time but a tiny budget
Good one?
#37 · Would you rather
Open
A) stay up all night to finish a game and wreck your whole next day B) put it down now and lose the immersion you finally got into
Good one?
#38 · Would you rather
Open
A) get a troll in your ranked match every night B) queue alone with silent strangers forever
Good one?
#39 · Would you rather
Open
A) let players mod your game freely and lose control of its vision B) lock it down to keep your vision but kill the community around it
Good one?
#40 · Would you rather
Open
A) hire the genius who wrecks your studio's mood B) keep the calm team that ships slowly
Good one?
#41 · Would you rather
Open
A) sell your studio for life-changing money but lose all creative control B) keep full creative control but always scrape by financially
Good one?
#42 · Would you rather
Open
A) release your game to glowing reviews but terrible sales B) get mediocre reviews but sell millions of copies
Good one?
#43 · Would you rather
Open
A) own every dlc for your game but never finish it B) finish it and never buy anything new
Good one?
#44 · Would you rather
Open
A) cancel your studio's game after four years B) ship it knowing everyone will forget it
Good one?
#45 · Would you rather
Open
A) make your game harder than most players can take B) make it easy and let critics call it shallow
Good one?
#46 · Would you rather
Open
A) finish a game but have the ending spoiled an hour before B) stay unspoiled but never get to finish it
Good one?
#47 · Would you rather
Open
A) work at a famous studio making sequels forever B) work at a tiny studio on your dream game that may never ship
Good one?
#48 · Would you rather
Open
A) spend a year fixing every bug in your game and shipping no new features B) ship exciting new features on top of a buggy foundation
Good one?
#49 · Would you rather
Open
A) get brutally honest feedback on your game that crushes your morale B) get only polite praise that tells you nothing useful
Good one?
#50 · Would you rather
Open
A) lose all your progress in your favorite game B) keep it but never be allowed to play a new game again
Good one?

About gaming dilemmas

Would You Rather questions for gamers and game devs — agonizing gamedev trade-offs and pure gamer dilemmas that put you in a real pickle. Every question below shows the live global split once you pick a side, so you can find out whether your take is genuinely rare or whether half the internet agrees with you. Nothing is behind a sign-up, and the questions are free to read out loud, print, or play on a big screen.

Related categories

Funny Random Deep / Philosophical Gross Difficult Superpowers