What are magic school Would You Rather questions?

These are fantasy-themed Would You Rather questions that explore magical dilemmas about spells, creatures, artifacts, and life at an enchanted school.

Who are these questions for?

Perfect for fantasy fans, book clubs, themed parties, or anyone who loves imagining life with magical powers.

Can I use these for a themed party?

Absolutely! These questions are perfect for wizard-themed parties, Halloween gatherings, or fantasy game nights.

Back to Home

picklepicker.lol

School of Magic Would You Rather

Step into a world of magic and wonder with these enchanting Would You Rather questions. Perfect for fans of wizarding adventures, magical schools, and fantastical dilemmas.

Get as PDF →

Magical Powers & Abilities

1.Would you rather...
Open
A) be able to fly on a broomstick B) teleport anywhere instantly
Rate this question
2.Would you rather...
Open
A) read minds B) see the future in visions
Rate this question
3.Would you rather...
Open
A) speak to all animals B) speak every ancient magical language
Rate this question
4.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a wand that never fails B) wandless magic with half the power
Rate this question
5.Would you rather...
Open
A) brew any potion perfectly B) cast any spell on the first try
Rate this question
6.Would you rather...
Open
A) have an invisibility cloak B) a map that shows everyone's location
Rate this question
7.Would you rather...
Open
A) transform into any animal at will B) make any object come to life
Rate this question
8.Would you rather...
Open
A) control fire B) control water
Rate this question
9.Would you rather...
Open
A) heal any wound with magic B) protect anyone from any curse
Rate this question
10.Would you rather...
Open
A) erase specific memories B) relive any memory perfectly
Rate this question
11.Would you rather...
Open
A) create illusions so real no one can tell B) see through any illusion or lie
Rate this question
12.Would you rather...
Open
A) summon a guardian spirit to protect you B) have a familiar that shares your thoughts
Rate this question

School of Magic Life

1.Would you rather...
Open
A) be sorted into the house of the brave B) the house of the clever
Rate this question
2.Would you rather...
Open
A) be the best at dueling B) the best at potion-making
Rate this question
3.Would you rather...
Open
A) live in a tower with an amazing view B) in cozy underground chambers
Rate this question
4.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a strict but brilliant teacher B) a kind but disorganized one
Rate this question
5.Would you rather...
Open
A) win the house cup every year B) win the magical sports championship once
Rate this question
6.Would you rather...
Open
A) attend a magic school in a castle B) on a hidden tropical island
Rate this question
7.Would you rather...
Open
A) study dark arts defense B) care for magical creatures
Rate this question
8.Would you rather...
Open
A) have enchanted homework that writes itself B) a library book that answers any question
Rate this question
9.Would you rather...
Open
A) be prefect with responsibilities B) a regular student with more free time
Rate this question
10.Would you rather...
Open
A) take your exams with a time-turner B) with a perfect memory potion
Rate this question
11.Would you rather...
Open
A) learn magic from ancient books B) from a legendary wizard mentor
Rate this question
12.Would you rather...
Open
A) attend the Yule Ball as the guest of honor B) organize the best party in common room history
Rate this question

Magical Creatures

1.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a phoenix as a companion B) a dragon
Rate this question
2.Would you rather...
Open
A) ride a hippogriff B) a flying horse with wings
Rate this question
3.Would you rather...
Open
A) befriend a giant B) a colony of intelligent spiders
Rate this question
4.Would you rather...
Open
A) own a three-headed dog B) a cat that detects lies
Rate this question
5.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a house-elf helper B) a goblin financial advisor
Rate this question
6.Would you rather...
Open
A) swim with merpeople B) explore caves with friendly trolls
Rate this question
7.Would you rather...
Open
A) communicate with ghosts B) command an army of enchanted suits of armor
Rate this question
8.Would you rather...
Open
A) care for baby unicorns B) raise a magical serpent
Rate this question
9.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a pet owl for mail B) a cat that can turn into a cup
Rate this question
10.Would you rather...
Open
A) encounter a werewolf on a full moon B) a vampire at midnight
Rate this question
11.Would you rather...
Open
A) be able to see thestrals B) be invisible to all magical creatures
Rate this question
12.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a boggart as a pet B) a dementor that only scares your enemies
Rate this question

Magical Dilemmas

1.Would you rather...
Open
A) use a love potion once B) never be able to fall in love naturally
Rate this question
2.Would you rather...
Open
A) be immortal but alone B) mortal with loved ones
Rate this question
3.Would you rather...
Open
A) know you'll defeat the dark lord but die doing it B) live in hiding forever
Rate this question
4.Would you rather...
Open
A) have power over death B) the wisdom to accept it
Rate this question
5.Would you rather...
Open
A) break an unbreakable vow to save a friend B) keep it and lose them
Rate this question
6.Would you rather...
Open
A) sacrifice your magic to save the wizarding world B) keep it while others suffer
Rate this question
7.Would you rather...
Open
A) be a powerful dark wizard who repents B) a weak good wizard who never wavers
Rate this question
8.Would you rather...
Open
A) know the prophecy about your fate B) live in blissful ignorance
Rate this question
9.Would you rather...
Open
A) use forbidden magic for good B) only use approved spells even when losing
Rate this question
10.Would you rather...
Open
A) trust a reformed villain B) suspect a seeming hero
Rate this question
11.Would you rather...
Open
A) have your greatest fear known to everyone B) never face it and never grow
Rate this question
12.Would you rather...
Open
A) split your soul for immortality B) die whole and at peace
Rate this question

Magical Artifacts & Objects

1.Would you rather...
Open
A) own the most powerful wand in existence B) a stone that brings back the dead briefly
Rate this question
2.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a pensieve to store memories B) a mirror that shows your heart's desire
Rate this question
3.Would you rather...
Open
A) possess a sword that appears when you're brave B) a hat that reads your mind
Rate this question
4.Would you rather...
Open
A) own a trunk with infinite space inside B) a tent that's a mansion inside
Rate this question
5.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a clock that shows where everyone is B) a sneakoscope that detects all lies
Rate this question
6.Would you rather...
Open
A) carry a bag of endless gold coins B) a portkey that takes you anywhere once a day
Rate this question
7.Would you rather...
Open
A) own enchanted chess pieces that win every game B) a quill that writes perfect essays
Rate this question
8.Would you rather...
Open
A) have a foe-glass to see enemies approaching B) a put-outer that controls all lights
Rate this question
9.Would you rather...
Open
A) possess a time-turner B) a remembrall that shows forgotten memories
Rate this question
10.Would you rather...
Open
A) own a howler that scares your enemies B) a love letter that writes the perfect words
Rate this question
11.Would you rather...
Open
A) have the Marauder's Map of your city B) an invisibility cloak that lasts one hour daily
Rate this question
12.Would you rather...
Open
A) possess a bezoar that cures any poison B) felix felicis for one perfect day a year
Rate this question

How to Play Magic School Would You Rather

Would You Rather gets a magical twist with these enchanting questions.

Gather your fellow wizards and witches
Take turns reading magical dilemmas aloud
Everyone must choose one option - no using magic to pick both!
Explain your reasoning and debate the merits of each choice

Magical Tips:

Dress up in robes for extra immersion
Sort players into houses for team debates
Award points for the most creative explanations

Pro tip: The best debates happen when both options seem equally magical or equally terrifying!

Why These Magical Questions Enchant Players

Escape Reality

Transport yourself to a world of magic and wonder.

Reveal Your Inner Wizard

Discover what kind of magical person you'd really be.

Perfect for Fantasy Fans

Questions that resonate with lovers of magical worlds.

Endless Debates

Magical dilemmas that spark imagination and discussion.